cc: "'Wei-Chyung Wang'" <wang@climate.cestm.albany.edu>
date: Wed, 15 Apr 2009 12:14:14 -0400
from: "Wei-Chyung Wang" <wang@climate.cestm.albany.edu>
subject: FW: FW: National Science Foundation funded grant proposals - 
to: "'Phil Jones'" <p.jones@uea.ac.uk>

   See SUNYA's response below.  My frustration has been that I do not know how to take the
   legal action.  Along this line, I wish he is a US resident so that I can sue him.


   WCW

   From: Lynn Videka [mailto:lvideka@uamail.albany.edu]
   Sent: Wednesday, April 15, 2009 12:04 PM
   To: Wei-Chyung Wang
   Cc: Wei-Chyung Wang; John H Reilly; Adrienne D Bonilla
   Subject: RE: FW: National Science Foundation funded grant proposals - Response required


   Wei-Chyung,


   I spoke to Adrienne this morning about the residency questions re FOIL and she will look
   into it.  I will meet with John and George Philip very soon to discuss the institutions'
   response.


   FYI,  Keenan has tried to FOIL our misconduct file and the university has determined that
   he is not eligible to FOIL those files.


   Lynn


   Lynn Videka
   Vice President for Research
   Distinguished Service Professor
   University at Albany-State University of New York
   University Hall, 307
   Albany, NY 12222
   (518) 956-8170 ; FAX (518)956-8175
   Secretary: Terri Casey at the above number

   ___________________________________________________________________________________________

   From: Wei-Chyung Wang [mailto:wang@climate.cestm.albany.edu]
   Sent: Wednesday, April 15, 2009 12:00 PM
   To: Lynn Videka
   Cc: Wei-Chyung Wang
   Subject: FW: FW: National Science Foundation funded grant proposals - Response required


   Hi, Lynn,


   Sorry for rushing the following e-mail from Phil Jones to you.   NSF's deadline is within
   five days of receiving the e-mail this morning.


   It turns out that Professor Ray Bradley of Univ. of Massachusetts-Amherst (together with
   Professor Malcolm Hughes of Univ. of Arizona) has encountered similar situation related to
   Hockey Stick.  I will try to contact Ray and will let you know.


   WCW

   From: Phil Jones [mailto:p.jones@uea.ac.uk]
   Sent: Wednesday, April 15, 2009 10:55 AM
   To: Wei-Chyung Wang; 'Thomas.R.Karl'
   Cc: 'Wei-Chyung Wang'
   Subject: Re: FW: National Science Foundation funded grant proposals - Response required


    Wei-Chyung,
       Do ask them! This looks as though it could get out of control. Look
    at the tone of some of the recent things on his web site.
     Also - send an email to Ray Bradley. He has been through this related
    to the Hockey Stick work with Mike Mann and Malcolm Hughes. They ere
    asked by a congressman or senator for details of all their grants.
    Also ask SUNYA if Keenan has to be US (and/or live in the US) to file
    US FOI requests.
    Cheers
    Phil