cc: p.jones@uea, pittock@uea.ac.uk, a.minns@uea.ac.uk, Wolfgang Cramer , , simon.torok@csiro.au date: Thu, 10 Jul 2003 07:41:07 +1200 from: "Jim Salinger" subject: Re: cc. of letter to Climate Research to: , Robert wilby , tim.carter@vyh.fi, "N.W.Arnell" , p.martens@icis.unimaas.nl, Peter.Whetton@csiro.au, Mike Hulme Dear Mike et al I have just heard from a member of the department that the Editor who handled the Soon and Baliunas paper that Otto Kinne asked for an explanation of the criticisms. The Editor has given these. Apparently Otto Kinne has accepted these and plans to take no further action. It is interesting to note that my informant also received the Soon and Baliunas manuscript for review, and strongly recommended rejection. I may be in position tio learn more this evening. Adios for now Jim On 12 Jun 2003 at 17:28, Mike Hulme wrote: Dear Climate Research Review Editor, Below is the letter that I have just sent to the publisher of Climate Research - Otto Kinne. I am copying this to you all (including ccs) since in my original email of 16 April which originally raised my concerns I said I would keep you informed of my actions. The letter is self-explanatory. Feel free to use this letter if you wish to follow up directly with the journal. I have made my position clear. Mike ______________________________________________________________________ ___ ******************************************** Dr Jim Salinger, CRSNZ Tel: + 64 9 375 2053 NIWA Fax: + 64 9 375 2051 P O Box 109 695, (269 Khyber Pass Road) e-mail: j.salinger@niwa.co.nz Newmarket, Auckland, New Zealand *******************************************************************************************