cc: Anders Moberg , Martin Juckes , Eduardo.Zorita@gkss.de, hegerl@duke.edu, esper@wsl.ch, m.allen1@physics.ox.ac.uk, t.osborn@uea.ac.uk date: Tue, 25 Sep 2007 14:03:03 +0000 from: Nanne Weber subject: Re: Fwd: cp-2006-0049 - Manuscript will be published (M38) to: Keith Briffa Hi Keith and others, To me it seems that the lesson is more not to write a paper about the hockeystick - this subject is completely politicised and there is nothing but antagonism on all sides. See also the mail by Tim. My other experiences with Climate of the Past are all positive, good reviews, fast review process, etc. Most journals seem to make a mess of it as soon as 'hockeystick' is involved. Best, Nanne Keith Briffa wrote: >> ditto Ander's remark - but it is a lesson to me at least not to >> submit here again! > > At 13:44 24/09/2007, Anders Moberg wrote: >> Hi Martin, >> >> That's good news! Thanks for all your efforts. >> >> cheers, >> Anders >> >> >> Martin Juckes wrote: >> > Hello, >> > >> > Our paper has been accepted at last! Thanks for all your >> contributions and >> > patience. Hughes Goosse has added the final editorial comment to >> the CPD we >> > site, saying that our outstanding differences with the reviewer >> (i.e. Gerd >> > Burger) are reasonable and expressed in a balanced way: >> > http://www.cosis.net/link.php?ts=jeav&ms_id=5220&uid=38478 >> > >> > There was, long ago, discussion of a press release -- does anyone >> think this >> > is a good idea now? >> > >> > cheers, >> > Martin >> > >> > ---------- Forwarded Message ---------- >> > >> > Subject: cp-2006-0049 - Manuscript will be published (M38) >> > Date: Friday 21 September 2007 12:22 >> > From: publishing@cosis.net >> > To: m.n.juckes@rl.ac.uk >> > >> > Dear Dr. Martin Juckes, >> > >> > We are pleased to inform you that your manuscript cp-2006-0049 is >> acceptable >> > as it is for publication. >> > >> > You will receive further information directly from the Production >> Office. >> > >> > For this manuscript please use your COSIS-ID: 38478 >> > >> > Kind regards, >> > Natascha Otto >> > Copernicus Editorial Office >> > http://www.climate-of-the-past.net >> > >> > PS: If you have any questions/suggestions please contact me >> directly at >> > editorial@copernicus.org. >> > >> > Please do not directly reply to the sender of this automated message. >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > ------------------------------------------------------- >> > >> >> -- >> >