date: Mon, 13 Jun 2005 09:26:18 -0400 (EDT) from: hegerl@duke.edu subject: Re: request for data for IPCC AR4 figures to: Tim Osborn MOrning TIm, Uuups, its NH 30-90N as far as I remember. What do you want - no problem makeing something different! Also, what aerosols would you like? If you have no preference, I'll use my "standard" reasonable fit values with 2.5 sensitivity. Gabi On Mon, 13 Jun 2005, Tim Osborn wrote: > Thanks for the model simulated temperatures, Gabi. Could I just check > exactly what it is, because it seems to warm a little more than I was > expecting. > > Is it the full NH land & marine, annual-mean temperature. This is what I want. > > Or is it 30-90N mean or something else? > > Cheers > > Tim > > At 22:20 10/06/2005, you wrote: > >Tim, > > > >I append the all forcings run with sensitivity 2.5, a mid-range aerosol > >forcing (-1.5 NH 30-90N mean), > >and a mid-range ocean heat uptake. > >Tom uses the old Mitchell et al97 direct aerosol forcing timeseries, > >contact us if you need to know more. > >He promised to send his volcano forcing. > >He also said he'd send the reconstruction (its actually 3, a short densely > >sampled one, and two longer > >less densely sampled ones stacked into one another). The errobars are for > >decadal data, if you want I > >can make you 30-yr errorbars (not magic but takes a bit). > >I also hope Tom remembers if he got the 90% or 95% errorbars stored! > > > >The paper sigh is just being reformatted for another journal, but no major > >changes. > >THe GRL paper is still an ok reference for the runs, although the best > >reference is the sensitivity estimate > >paper that is also being reformatted to another journal - I can send it to > >you as soon as we get there. > > > >Hope this helps, let me know what else is needed (sorry need to run now so > >no time for checkign) > > > >Gabi > > > > > > > >Tim Osborn wrote: > > > >>At 14:58 10/06/2005, you wrote: > >> > >>>Its actually my fault, I woke up this morning remembering that I STILL > >>>didn't send you these data. > >>>I think you need the new timeseries, and I'll let you know the anomalies. > >> > >> > >>Thanks. Have you heard anything back from the journal yet? > >> > >>> I also promised the > >>>simulation - all forcings. > >> > >> > >>What is the reference for this (presumably new) model run - is it the > >>same as your submitted paper describing the new reconstruction? > >> > >>> Is this afternoon ok? > >>> Totally ok to say you need it right now (I'd prefer > >>>to do something else first that needs to go out, but I can change plan) > >> > >> > >>Please don't change your plans! Just send it as soon as you have a spare > >>moment (I realise - having no spare moments of my own - that this might > >>mean never! but of course I don't really mean that!). > >> > >>>There is some difference in the volcanic forcing, but I THINK (TOM??) > >>>not in the others. > >>>Tom would need to send the new volcanic forcing (used for the > >>>megaensemble Tom). > >> > >> > >>Ok. I have the solar which sounds like it is unchanged. Tom will > >>hopefully send the revised volcanic. The figure also has a panel "all > >>other forcings", which I don't have for your simulations - hence that > >>would be good too. I don't mind adding them up if you have separate time > >>series for GHG, SO4, etc. > >> > >>>Promise will happen today, I am sorry for being slack on this (I bet you > >>>know the reason ;) > >> > >> > >>You haven't been slack at all - it's my responsibility to get the figure > >>done. > >> > >>Thanks for your help > >> > >>Tim > >> > >> > >> > >>Dr Timothy J Osborn > >>Climatic Research Unit > >>School of Environmental Sciences, University of East Anglia > >>Norwich NR4 7TJ, UK > >> > >>e-mail: t.osborn@uea.ac.uk > >>phone: +44 1603 592089 > >>fax: +44 1603 507784 > >>web: http://www.cru.uea.ac.uk/~timo/ > >>sunclock: http://www.cru.uea.ac.uk/~timo/sunclock.htm > > > >-- > >~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ > >Gabriele Hegerl Division of Earth and Ocean Sciences, Nicholas School for > >the Environment and Earth Sciences, > >Box 90227 > >Duke University, Durham NC 27708 > >Ph: 919 684 6167, fax 684 5833 > >email: hegerl@duke.edu, http://www.env.duke.edu/faculty/bios/hegerl.html > > > > > > > > 1000 -0.0054 > > 1001 -0.0084 > > 1002 -0.0098 > > 1003 -0.0645 > > 1004 -0.0887 > > 1005 -0.0644 > > 1006 -0.0443 > > 1007 -0.0476 > > 1008 -0.0479 > > 1009 -0.0347 > > 1010 -0.0252 > > 1011 -0.0200 > > 1012 -0.0188 > > 1013 -0.0197 > > 1014 -0.0216 > > 1015 -0.0243 > > 1016 -0.0276 > > 1017 -0.0313 > > 1018 -0.0694 > > 1019 -0.0890 > > 1020 -0.0777 > > 1021 -0.0679 > > 1022 -0.0608 > > 1023 -0.0580 > > 1024 -0.1009 > > 1025 -0.1203 > > 1026 -0.1004 > > 1027 -0.0844 > > 1028 -0.0728 > > 1029 -0.0673 > > 1030 -0.0646 > > 1031 -0.0635 > > 1032 -0.0632 > > 1033 -0.0637 > > 1034 -0.0648 > > 1035 -0.0659 > > 1036 -0.0670 > > 1037 -0.0682 > > 1038 -0.0694 > > 1039 -0.0707 > > 1040 -0.0718 > > 1041 -0.0722 > > 1042 -0.0720 > > 1043 -0.0714 > > 1044 -0.0705 > > 1045 -0.0694 > > 1046 -0.0682 > > 1047 -0.0669 > > 1048 -0.0655 > > 1049 -0.0640 > > 1050 -0.0627 > > 1051 -0.0616 > > 1052 -0.0607 > > 1053 -0.0599 > > 1054 -0.0591 > > 1055 -0.0584 > > 1056 -0.0577 > > 1057 -0.0571 > > 1058 -0.0564 > > 1059 -0.0558 > > 1060 -0.0553 > > 1061 -0.0549 > > 1062 -0.0858 > > 1063 -0.0997 > > 1064 -0.0856 > > 1065 -0.0742 > > 1066 -0.0907 > > 1067 -0.0980 > > 1068 -0.0848 > > 1069 -0.0745 > > 1070 -0.0669 > > 1071 -0.0622 > > 1072 -0.0586 > > 1073 -0.0556 > > 1074 -0.0527 > > 1075 -0.0500 > > 1076 -0.0478 > > 1077 -0.0464 > > 1078 -0.0444 > > 1079 -0.0421 > > 1080 -0.0398 > > 1081 -0.0376 > > 1082 -0.0356 > > 1083 -0.0519 > > 1084 -0.0580 > > 1085 -0.0476 > > 1086 -0.0388 > > 1087 -0.0317 > > 1088 -0.0266 > > 1089 -0.0218 > > 1090 -0.0182 > > 1091 -0.0365 > > 1092 -0.0437 > > 1093 -0.0322 > > 1094 -0.0227 > > 1095 -0.0154 > > 1096 -0.0110 > > 1097 -0.0081 > > 1098 -0.0057 > > 1099 -0.0036 > > 1100 -0.0279 > > 1101 -0.0365 > > 1102 -0.0212 > > 1103 -0.0091 > > 1104 -0.0001 > > 1105 0.0049 > > 1106 0.0083 > > 1107 0.0108 > > 1108 0.0129 > > 1109 0.0148 > > 1110 0.0161 > > 1111 0.0166 > > 1112 0.0166 > > 1113 0.0163 > > 1114 0.0157 > > 1115 0.0149 > > 1116 -0.0076 > > 1117 -0.0347 > > 1118 -0.0369 > > 1119 -0.0320 > > 1120 -0.0248 > > 1121 -0.0187 > > 1122 -0.0138 > > 1123 -0.0098 > > 1124 -0.0065 > > 1125 -0.0037 > > 1126 -0.0013 > > 1127 0.0008 > > 1128 0.0027 > > 1129 0.0045 > > 1130 0.0067 > > 1131 0.0101 > > 1132 0.0142 > > 1133 0.0187 > > 1134 0.0235 > > 1135 0.0285 > > 1136 0.0338 > > 1137 0.0397 > > 1138 0.0465 > > 1139 0.0528 > > 1140 0.0579 > > 1141 0.0605 > > 1142 0.0617 > > 1143 0.0621 > > 1144 0.0618 > > 1145 0.0610 > > 1146 0.0598 > > 1147 0.0583 > > 1148 0.0565 > > 1149 0.0545 > > 1150 0.0521 > > 1151 0.0493 > > 1152 0.0462 > > 1153 0.0428 > > 1154 0.0391 > > 1155 0.0354 > > 1156 0.0314 > > 1157 0.0273 > > 1158 0.0232 > > 1159 0.0189 > > 1160 0.0154 > > 1161 0.0139 > > 1162 0.0135 > > 1163 0.0138 > > 1164 0.0147 > > 1165 0.0159 > > 1166 0.0180 > > 1167 0.0211 > > 1168 -0.0885 > > 1169 -0.1378 > > 1170 -0.0872 > > 1171 -0.0466 > > 1172 -0.0167 > > 1173 -0.0022 > > 1174 0.0058 > > 1175 0.0109 > > 1176 0.0145 > > 1177 0.0170 > > 1178 0.0181 > > 1179 0.0184 > > 1180 0.0186 > > 1181 0.0188 > > 1182 0.0188 > > 1183 0.0187 > > 1184 0.0179 > > 1185 0.0162 > > 1186 0.0149 > > 1187 0.0138 > > 1188 -0.0278 > > 1189 -0.0473 > > 1190 -0.0539 > > 1191 -0.0498 > > 1192 -0.0282 > > 1193 -0.0143 > > 1194 -0.0044 > > 1195 0.0019 > > 1196 -0.0292 > > 1197 -0.0416 > > 1198 -0.0223 > > 1199 -0.0061 > > 1200 0.0060 > > 1201 0.0119 > > 1202 0.0145 > > 1203 0.0148 > > 1204 0.0150 > > 1205 0.0149 > > 1206 -0.0067 > > 1207 -0.0169 > > 1208 -0.0084 > > 1209 -0.0018 > > 1210 0.0024 > > 1211 0.0034 > > 1212 0.0030 > > 1213 0.0014 > > 1214 -0.0014 > > 1215 -0.0039 > > 1216 -0.0062 > > 1217 -0.0086 > > 1218 -0.0111 > > 1219 -0.0137 > > 1220 -0.0157 > > 1221 -0.0170 > > 1222 -0.0183 > > 1223 -0.0186 > > 1224 -0.0183 > > 1225 -0.0425 > > 1226 -0.0528 > > 1227 -0.0405 > > 1228 -0.2691 > > 1229 -0.3691 > > 1230 -0.2581 > > 1231 -0.1697 > > 1232 -0.1079 > > 1233 -0.0812 > > 1234 -0.0670 > > 1235 -0.0576 > > 1236 -0.0507 > > 1237 -0.0453 > > 1238 -0.0410 > > 1239 -0.0374 > > 1240 -0.0344 > > 1241 -0.0317 > > 1242 -0.0292 > > 1243 -0.0269 > > 1244 -0.0248 > > 1245 -0.0229 > > 1246 -0.0210 > > 1247 -0.0193 > > 1248 -0.0176 > > 1249 -0.0160 > > 1250 -0.0149 > > 1251 -0.0255 > > 1252 -0.0307 > > 1253 -0.0263 > > 1254 -0.0231 > > 1255 -0.0211 > > 1256 -0.0208 > > 1257 -0.0213 > > 1258 -0.7395 > > 1259 -1.1808 > > 1260 -0.9350 > > 1261 -0.6878 > > 1262 -0.4842 > > 1263 -0.3714 > > 1264 -0.3014 > > 1265 -0.2530 > > 1266 -0.2175 > > 1267 -0.2367 > > 1268 -0.2364 > > 1269 -0.2003 > > 1270 -0.1725 > > 1271 -0.1511 > > 1272 -0.1377 > > 1273 -0.1283 > > 1274 -0.1212 > > 1275 -0.1158 > > 1276 -0.2556 > > 1277 -0.3861 > > 1278 -0.3647 > > 1279 -0.3193 > > 1280 -0.2720 > > 1281 -0.2385 > > 1282 -0.2144 > > 1283 -0.1957 > > 1284 -0.1802 > > 1285 -0.1683 > > 1286 -0.3874 > > 1287 -0.5363 > > 1288 -0.4623 > > 1289 -0.3804 > > 1290 -0.3095 > > 1291 -0.2667 > > 1292 -0.2379 > > 1293 -0.2180 > > 1294 -0.2034 > > 1295 -0.1921 > > 1296 -0.1826 > > 1297 -0.1975 > > 1298 -0.2022 > > 1299 -0.1885 > > 1300 -0.1771 > > 1301 -0.1672 > > 1302 -0.1600 > > 1303 -0.1541 > > 1304 -0.1488 > > 1305 -0.1438 > > 1306 -0.1391 > > 1307 -0.1346 > > 1308 -0.1302 > > 1309 -0.1260 > > 1310 -0.1221 > > 1311 -0.1190 > > 1312 -0.1163 > > 1313 -0.1139 > > 1314 -0.1118 > > 1315 -0.1098 > > 1316 -0.1080 > > 1317 -0.1063 > > 1318 -0.1048 > > 1319 -0.1033 > > 1320 -0.1023 > > 1321 -0.1023 > > 1322 -0.1030 > > 1323 -0.1039 > > 1324 -0.1048 > > 1325 -0.1407 > > 1326 -0.1576 > > 1327 -0.1433 > > 1328 -0.1322 > > 1329 -0.1246 > > 1330 -0.1210 > > 1331 -0.1396 > > 1332 -0.1459 > > 1333 -0.1322 > > 1334 -0.1208 > > 1335 -0.1122 > > 1336 -0.1057 > > 1337 -0.1002 > > 1338 -0.0949 > > 1339 -0.0898 > > 1340 -0.0849 > > 1341 -0.0979 > > 1342 -0.1021 > > 1343 -0.0917 > > 1344 -0.0823 > > 1345 -0.3058 > > 1346 -0.4490 > > 1347 -0.3695 > > 1348 -0.2866 > > 1349 -0.2170 > > 1350 -0.1769 > > 1351 -0.1511 > > 1352 -0.1326 > > 1353 -0.1188 > > 1354 -0.1080 > > 1355 -0.0993 > > 1356 -0.0923 > > 1357 -0.0868 > > 1358 -0.0831 > > 1359 -0.0793 > > 1360 -0.0754 > > 1361 -0.0708 > > 1362 -0.0658 > > 1363 -0.0605 > > 1364 -0.0557 > > 1365 -0.0516 > > 1366 -0.0474 > > 1367 -0.0437 > > 1368 -0.0392 > > 1369 -0.0344 > > 1370 -0.0304 > > 1371 -0.0281 > > 1372 -0.0269 > > 1373 -0.0264 > > 1374 -0.0264 > > 1375 -0.0267 > > 1376 -0.0463 > > 1377 -0.0569 > > 1378 -0.0506 > > 1379 -0.0458 > > 1380 -0.0427 > > 1381 -0.0420 > > 1382 -0.0717 > > 1383 -0.0857 > > 1384 -0.0736 > > 1385 -0.0644 > > 1386 -0.0581 > > 1387 -0.0559 > > 1388 -0.0555 > > 1389 -0.0990 > > 1390 -0.1194 > > 1391 -0.1006 > > 1392 -0.0850 > > 1393 -0.0750 > > 1394 -0.0720 > > 1395 -0.0711 > > 1396 -0.0711 > > 1397 -0.0716 > > 1398 -0.0725 > > 1399 -0.0737 > > 1400 -0.0749 > > 1401 -0.0753 > > 1402 -0.0749 > > 1403 -0.0751 > > 1404 -0.0755 > > 1405 -0.0759 > > 1406 -0.0765 > > 1407 -0.0770 > > 1408 -0.0776 > > 1409 -0.0782 > > 1410 -0.0783 > > 1411 -0.0774 > > 1412 -0.0772 > > 1413 -0.0771 > > 1414 -0.0772 > > 1415 -0.0772 > > 1416 -0.0773 > > 1417 -0.0774 > > 1418 -0.0776 > > 1419 -0.0777 > > 1420 -0.0775 > > 1421 -0.0767 > > 1422 -0.0769 > > 1423 -0.0773 > > 1424 -0.0780 > > 1425 -0.0788 > > 1426 -0.0797 > > 1427 -0.0807 > > 1428 -0.0817 > > 1429 -0.0828 > > 1430 -0.0842 > > 1431 -0.0862 > > 1432 -0.0885 > > 1433 -0.0911 > > 1434 -0.0939 > > 1435 -0.0968 > > 1436 -0.0998 > > 1437 -0.1029 > > 1438 -0.1062 > > 1439 -0.1095 > > 1440 -0.1125 > > 1441 -0.1152 > > 1442 -0.1717 > > 1443 -0.1980 > > 1444 -0.1760 > > 1445 -0.1584 > > 1446 -0.1459 > > 1447 -0.1416 > > 1448 -0.1415 > > 1449 -0.1416 > > 1450 -0.1415 > > 1451 -0.1414 > > 1452 -0.1419 > > 1453 -0.3236 > > 1454 -0.4920 > > 1455 -0.4675 > > 1456 -0.4123 > > 1457 -0.3535 > > 1458 -0.3121 > > 1459 -0.2830 > > 1460 -0.3580 > > 1461 -0.3844 > > 1462 -0.3268 > > 1463 -0.2809 > > 1464 -0.2468 > > 1465 -0.2491 > > 1466 -0.2460 > > 1467 -0.2266 > > 1468 -0.2112 > > 1469 -0.2138 > > 1470 -0.2125 > > 1471 -0.2003 > > 1472 -0.1906 > > 1473 -0.1832 > > 1474 -0.1784 > > 1475 -0.1749 > > 1476 -0.1721 > > 1477 -0.1693 > > 1478 -0.1661 > > 1479 -0.1639 > > 1480 -0.2170 > > 1481 -0.2403 > > 1482 -0.2440 > > 1483 -0.2352 > > 1484 -0.2055 > > 1485 -0.1863 > > 1486 -0.1730 > > 1487 -0.1646 > > 1488 -0.1594 > > 1489 -0.1557 > > 1490 -0.1526 > > 1491 -0.1491 > > 1492 -0.1448 > > 1493 -0.1697 > > 1494 -0.1793 > > 1495 -0.1624 > > 1496 -0.1466 > > 1497 -0.1351 > > 1498 -0.1279 > > 1499 -0.1226 > > 1500 -0.1184 > > 1501 -0.1144 > > 1502 -0.1102 > > 1503 -0.1362 > > 1504 -0.1469 > > 1505 -0.1315 > > 1506 -0.1189 > > 1507 -0.1092 > > 1508 -0.1036 > > 1509 -0.0997 > > 1510 -0.0964 > > 1511 -0.0933 > > 1512 -0.2074 > > 1513 -0.2587 > > 1514 -0.2063 > > 1515 -0.1643 > > 1516 -0.1342 > > 1517 -0.1202 > > 1518 -0.1132 > > 1519 -0.1091 > > 1520 -0.1065 > > 1521 -0.1045 > > 1522 -0.1028 > > 1523 -0.1013 > > 1524 -0.0999 > > 1525 -0.1142 > > 1526 -0.1201 > > 1527 -0.1121 > > 1528 -0.1056 > > 1529 -0.1006 > > 1530 -0.0971 > > 1531 -0.0932 > > 1532 -0.0900 > > 1533 -0.0877 > > 1534 -0.0862 > > 1535 -0.0842 > > 1536 -0.0822 > > 1537 -0.0799 > > 1538 -0.0775 > > 1539 -0.0750 > > 1540 -0.0726 > > 1541 -0.0703 > > 1542 -0.0682 > > 1543 -0.0661 > > 1544 -0.0641 > > 1545 -0.0621 > > 1546 -0.0602 > > 1547 -0.0582 > > 1548 -0.0566 > > 1549 -0.0554 > > 1550 -0.0539 > > 1551 -0.0522 > > 1552 -0.0504 > > 1553 -0.0484 > > 1554 -0.1061 > > 1555 -0.1316 > > 1556 -0.1043 > > 1557 -0.0815 > > 1558 -0.0645 > > 1559 -0.0556 > > 1560 -0.0501 > > 1561 -0.0462 > > 1562 -0.0696 > > 1563 -0.0791 > > 1564 -0.0649 > > 1565 -0.0535 > > 1566 -0.0449 > > 1567 -0.0404 > > 1568 -0.0384 > > 1569 -0.0365 > > 1570 -0.0347 > > 1571 -0.0725 > > 1572 -0.0888 > > 1573 -0.0697 > > 1574 -0.0548 > > 1575 -0.0446 > > 1576 -0.0391 > > 1577 -0.0357 > > 1578 -0.0337 > > 1579 -0.0329 > > 1580 -0.0465 > > 1581 -0.0524 > > 1582 -0.0460 > > 1583 -0.0407 > > 1584 -0.0373 > > 1585 -0.0352 > > 1586 -0.0542 > > 1587 -0.3537 > > 1588 -0.3543 > > 1589 -0.2711 > > 1590 -0.2182 > > 1591 -0.1774 > > 1592 -0.1433 > > 1593 -0.1316 > > 1594 -0.1501 > > 1595 -0.1449 > > 1596 -0.1326 > > 1597 -0.1185 > > 1598 -0.1062 > > 1599 -0.0968 > > 1600 -0.4064 > > 1601 -0.6868 > > 1602 -0.5638 > > 1603 -0.4293 > > 1604 -0.3181 > > 1605 -0.2567 > > 1606 -0.2191 > > 1607 -0.1938 > > 1608 -0.1764 > > 1609 -0.1632 > > 1610 -0.1528 > > 1611 -0.1446 > > 1612 -0.1383 > > 1613 -0.1336 > > 1614 -0.1296 > > 1615 -0.1261 > > 1616 -0.1231 > > 1617 -0.1205 > > 1618 -0.1183 > > 1619 -0.1165 > > 1620 -0.1275 > > 1621 -0.1905 > > 1622 -0.1850 > > 1623 -0.1666 > > 1624 -0.1498 > > 1625 -0.1377 > > 1626 -0.1308 > > 1627 -0.1263 > > 1628 -0.1227 > > 1629 -0.1192 > > 1630 -0.1172 > > 1631 -0.1162 > > 1632 -0.1154 > > 1633 -0.1155 > > 1634 -0.1153 > > 1635 -0.1146 > > 1636 -0.1148 > > 1637 -0.1154 > > 1638 -0.2233 > > 1639 -0.2869 > > 1640 -0.2720 > > 1641 -0.4836 > > 1642 -0.6308 > > 1643 -0.5234 > > 1644 -0.4024 > > 1645 -0.3146 > > 1646 -0.2653 > > 1647 -0.2547 > > 1648 -0.2313 > > 1649 -0.2107 > > 1650 -0.1956 > > 1651 -0.1850 > > 1652 -0.1776 > > 1653 -0.1722 > > 1654 -0.1683 > > 1655 -0.1658 > > 1656 -0.1638 > > 1657 -0.1620 > > 1658 -0.1606 > > 1659 -0.1595 > > 1660 -0.1587 > > 1661 -0.1582 > > 1662 -0.1586 > > 1663 -0.1599 > > 1664 -0.1609 > > 1665 -0.1618 > > 1666 -0.1627 > > 1667 -0.1700 > > 1668 -0.3882 > > 1669 -0.3791 > > 1670 -0.3082 > > 1671 -0.2583 > > 1672 -0.2260 > > 1673 -0.2488 > > 1674 -0.3553 > > 1675 -0.3340 > > 1676 -0.2968 > > 1677 -0.2656 > > 1678 -0.2464 > > 1679 -0.2355 > > 1680 -0.2402 > > 1681 -0.3331 > > 1682 -0.3229 > > 1683 -0.2916 > > 1684 -0.2658 > > 1685 -0.2484 > > 1686 -0.2385 > > 1687 -0.2319 > > 1688 -0.2277 > > 1689 -0.2430 > > 1690 -0.2478 > > 1691 -0.2366 > > 1692 -0.2272 > > 1693 -0.2326 > > 1694 -0.4196 > > 1695 -0.4265 > > 1696 -0.5141 > > 1697 -0.4683 > > 1698 -0.3953 > > 1699 -0.3420 > > 1700 -0.3036 > > 1701 -0.2799 > > 1702 -0.2631 > > 1703 -0.2505 > > 1704 -0.2408 > > 1705 -0.2327 > > 1706 -0.2251 > > 1707 -0.2189 > > 1708 -0.2136 > > 1709 -0.2090 > > 1710 -0.2046 > > 1711 -0.2002 > > 1712 -0.1962 > > 1713 -0.1920 > > 1714 -0.1874 > > 1715 -0.1828 > > 1716 -0.1780 > > 1717 -0.1733 > > 1718 -0.1686 > > 1719 -0.1640 > > 1720 -0.1593 > > 1721 -0.1544 > > 1722 -0.1499 > > 1723 -0.1461 > > 1724 -0.1416 > > 1725 -0.1478 > > 1726 -0.1478 > > 1727 -0.1380 > > 1728 -0.1291 > > 1729 -0.1217 > > 1730 -0.1170 > > 1731 -0.1477 > > 1732 -0.1600 > > 1733 -0.1415 > > 1734 -0.1264 > > 1735 -0.1148 > > 1736 -0.1081 > > 1737 -0.1035 > > 1738 -0.0998 > > 1739 -0.1021 > > 1740 -0.1882 > > 1741 -0.1757 > > 1742 -0.1434 > > 1743 -0.1206 > > 1744 -0.1059 > > 1745 -0.0985 > > 1746 -0.0933 > > 1747 -0.0887 > > 1748 -0.0855 > > 1749 -0.0832 > > 1750 -0.0810 > > 1751 -0.0785 > > 1752 -0.0759 > > 1753 -0.0732 > > 1754 -0.0704 > > 1755 -0.0676 > > 1756 -0.0653 > > 1757 -0.0638 > > 1758 -0.0616 > > 1759 -0.0592 > > 1760 -0.0570 > > 1761 -0.0546 > > 1762 -0.1106 > > 1763 -0.1352 > > 1764 -0.1068 > > 1765 -0.0832 > > 1766 -0.0658 > > 1767 -0.0564 > > 1768 -0.0498 > > 1769 -0.0900 > > 1770 -0.1053 > > 1771 -0.0797 > > 1772 -0.0572 > > 1773 -0.0396 > > 1774 -0.0284 > > 1775 -0.0193 > > 1776 -0.0106 > > 1777 -0.0037 > > 1778 0.0018 > > 1779 0.0077 > > 1780 0.0128 > > 1781 0.0155 > > 1782 0.0169 > > 1783 0.0011 > > 1784 -0.0845 > > 1785 -0.0644 > > 1786 -0.0342 > > 1787 -0.0122 > > 1788 -0.0003 > > 1789 0.0050 > > 1790 -0.0293 > > 1791 -0.0290 > > 1792 -0.0137 > > 1793 -0.0020 > > 1794 0.0081 > > 1795 0.0153 > > 1796 0.0209 > > 1797 0.0241 > > 1798 0.0252 > > 1799 0.0253 > > 1800 0.0247 > > 1801 0.0238 > > 1802 0.0225 > > 1803 0.0210 > > 1804 0.0191 > > 1805 0.0171 > > 1806 0.0155 > > 1807 0.0144 > > 1808 0.0126 > > 1809 -0.1410 > > 1810 -0.4491 > > 1811 -0.3860 > > 1812 -0.2857 > > 1813 -0.2134 > > 1814 -0.1664 > > 1815 -0.3297 > > 1816 -0.7065 > > 1817 -0.6092 > > 1818 -0.4630 > > 1819 -0.3364 > > 1820 -0.2579 > > 1821 -0.2075 > > 1822 -0.1706 > > 1823 -0.1414 > > 1824 -0.1184 > > 1825 -0.0998 > > 1826 -0.0840 > > 1827 -0.0700 > > 1828 -0.0569 > > 1829 -0.0469 > > 1830 -0.0805 > > 1831 -0.1434 > > 1832 -0.2657 > > 1833 -0.2130 > > 1834 -0.1494 > > 1835 -0.2771 > > 1836 -0.3586 > > 1837 -0.2786 > > 1838 -0.2018 > > 1839 -0.1392 > > 1840 -0.1257 > > 1841 -0.1109 > > 1842 -0.0806 > > 1843 -0.0706 > > 1844 -0.0783 > > 1845 -0.0543 > > 1846 -0.0323 > > 1847 -0.0144 > > 1848 -0.0014 > > 1849 0.0079 > > 1850 0.0153 > > 1851 0.0213 > > 1852 0.0268 > > 1853 0.0323 > > 1854 -0.0084 > > 1855 -0.0159 > > 1856 0.0070 > > 1857 0.0244 > > 1858 0.0376 > > 1859 0.0460 > > 1860 0.0515 > > 1861 0.0326 > > 1862 0.0154 > > 1863 0.0237 > > 1864 0.0363 > > 1865 0.0477 > > 1866 0.0563 > > 1867 0.0438 > > 1868 0.0409 > > 1869 0.0555 > > 1870 0.0668 > > 1871 0.0759 > > 1872 0.0824 > > 1873 0.0872 > > 1874 0.0914 > > 1875 0.0945 > > 1876 0.0979 > > 1877 0.1009 > > 1878 0.1031 > > 1879 0.1059 > > 1880 0.1081 > > 1881 0.1062 > > 1882 0.1080 > > 1883 0.0938 > > 1884 -0.1750 > > 1885 -0.1728 > > 1886 -0.0932 > > 1887 -0.0253 > > 1888 0.0228 > > 1889 0.0497 > > 1890 0.0689 > > 1891 0.0831 > > 1892 0.0937 > > 1893 0.1026 > > 1894 0.1107 > > 1895 0.1170 > > 1896 0.1222 > > 1897 0.1271 > > 1898 0.1322 > > 1899 0.1368 > > 1900 0.1422 > > 1901 0.1483 > > 1902 0.1540 > > 1903 0.0940 > > 1904 0.0914 > > 1905 0.1187 > > 1906 0.1429 > > 1907 0.1470 > > 1908 0.1425 > > 1909 0.1620 > > 1910 0.1795 > > 1911 0.1936 > > 1912 0.1691 > > 1913 0.0091 > > 1914 0.0540 > > 1915 0.1199 > > 1916 0.1567 > > 1917 0.1813 > > 1918 0.2045 > > 1919 0.2217 > > 1920 0.2351 > > 1921 0.2458 > > 1922 0.2551 > > 1923 0.2631 > > 1924 0.2469 > > 1925 0.2373 > > 1926 0.2553 > > 1927 0.2711 > > 1928 0.2851 > > 1929 0.2971 > > 1930 0.3072 > > 1931 0.3169 > > 1932 0.3270 > > 1933 0.3363 > > 1934 0.3448 > > 1935 0.3521 > > 1936 0.3588 > > 1937 0.3598 > > 1938 0.3590 > > 1939 0.3651 > > 1940 0.3731 > > 1941 0.3802 > > 1942 0.3865 > > 1943 0.3711 > > 1944 0.3652 > > 1945 0.3758 > > 1946 0.3841 > > 1947 0.3912 > > 1948 0.3945 > > 1949 0.3957 > > 1950 0.3972 > > 1951 0.3967 > > 1952 0.3849 > > 1953 0.3914 > > 1954 0.3986 > > 1955 0.4038 > > 1956 0.4076 > > 1957 0.4117 > > 1958 0.4157 > > 1959 0.4193 > > 1960 0.4167 > > 1961 0.4068 > > 1962 0.4054 > > 1963 0.3931 > > 1964 0.3433 > > 1965 0.3077 > > 1966 0.3147 > > 1967 0.3390 > > 1968 0.3385 > > 1969 0.3169 > > 1970 0.3453 > > 1971 0.3864 > > 1972 0.4180 > > 1973 0.4331 > > 1974 0.4388 > > 1975 0.4152 > > 1976 0.4381 > > 1977 0.4821 > > 1978 0.5187 > > 1979 0.5433 > > 1980 0.5751 > > 1981 0.5993 > > 1982 0.5528 > > 1983 0.3952 > > 1984 0.4441 > > 1985 0.5260 > > 1986 0.5756 > > 1987 0.6154 > > 1988 0.6612 > > 1989 0.7037 > > 1990 0.7357 > > 1991 0.7296 > > 1992 0.5345 > > 1993 0.5596 > > 1994 0.6365 > > 1995 0.6964 > > 1996 0.7457 > > 1997 0.7917 > > 1998 0.8404 > > 1999 0.8869 > > 2000 0.9286 > > 2001 0.9635 > > Dr Timothy J Osborn > Climatic Research Unit > School of Environmental Sciences, University of East Anglia > Norwich NR4 7TJ, UK > > e-mail: t.osborn@uea.ac.uk > phone: +44 1603 592089 > fax: +44 1603 507784 > web: http://www.cru.uea.ac.uk/~timo/ > sunclock: http://www.cru.uea.ac.uk/~timo/sunclock.htm > > -------------------------------------------------------------------- Gabriele Hegerl Dept. of Earth and Ocean Sciences, Nicholas School of the Environment Duke University, Durham NC 27708 phone 919-684-6167, fax 919-684-5833 email: hegerl@duke.edu http://www.eos.duke.edu/Faculty/hegerl.html ---------------------------------------------------------------------