date: Wed, 1 Mar 2006 08:53:37 -0500 from: "Wahl, Eugene R" subject: RE: Wahl Ammann Climatic Change article on MBH/MM to: "Keith Briffa" Hello Keith: We are very happy to be able to formally contribute. Meeting the deadline has been very satisfying. Best !!! in your IPCC work. Peace, Gene ________________________________ From: Keith Briffa [mailto:k.briffa@uea.ac.uk] Sent: Wed 3/1/2006 2:41 AM To: Wahl, Eugene R; Jonathan Overpeck Cc: Eystein Jansen; Caspar Ammann Subject: RE: Wahl Ammann Climatic Change article on MBH/MM great - thanks for this Eugene. Reference definitely included Keith At 02:42 01/03/2006, Wahl, Eugene R wrote: >Hello all: > >Good news this day. The Wahl-Ammann paper also has been given fully >accepted status today by Stephen Schneider. I copy his affirmation >of this below, and after that his remark from earlier this month >regarding this status being equivalent to "in press". I hope this >meets the deadline of before March 1 for citation. > >Peace, Gene > > >********************************* first copied message >************************************** > >RE: provision of Wahl and Ammann ms 3321 to NAS committee >Stephen H Schneider [shs@stanford.edu] > You replied on 2/28/2006 9:33 PM. > Follow up >To: Wahl, Eugene R >Cc: katarina kivel > >Hello from Sydney. I have now read your responses the the rereviewer and >am satisfied you have done more than an adequate job. The paper is now >accepted and you can post it where you wish with that designation. Let me >know if there is anything else to do. Congratulations, Steve > > > >********************************* second copied message >************************************** > >RE: Wahl and Ammann ms 3321 >Stephen H Schneider [shs@stanford.edu] > You replied on 2/28/2006 7:06 PM. > Follow up >To: Wahl, Eugene R >Cc: katarina kivel > >your interpretation is fine--get me the revision soon so I have time to >assess your responses in light of reviews in time! Look forward to >recievieng it, Steve > >On Sat, 11 Feb 2006, Wahl, Eugene R wrote: > > > Hello Steve: > > > > Caspar and I expect to have the final manuscript to you in 7-10 > days with all the revisions you requested in December. I have > recently had some correspondance with Jonathan Overpeck about this, > in his IPCC role. He says that the paper needs to be in press by > the end of February to be acceptable to be cited in the SOD. [I > had thought that we had passed all chance for citation in the next > IPCC report back in December, but Peck has made it known to me this is not so.] > > > > He and I have communicated re: what "in press" means for Climatic > Change, and I agreed to contact you to have a clear > definition. What I have understood from our conversations before > is that if you receive the mss and move it from "provisionally > accepted" status to "accepted", then this can be considered in > press, in light of CC being a journal of record. > > > > Peace, Gene > > Dr. Eugene R. Wahl > > Asst. Professor of Environmental Studies > > Alfred University > > > >*************************** end of copied messages ********************* > >Dr. Eugene R. Wahl >Asst. Professor of Environmental Studies >Alfred University > >607-871-2604 >1 Saxon Drive >Alfred, NY 14802 > > -- Professor Keith Briffa, Climatic Research Unit University of East Anglia Norwich, NR4 7TJ, U.K. Phone: +44-1603-593909 Fax: +44-1603-507784 http://www.cru.uea.ac.uk/cru/people/briffa/